Low Shelf

23 bottles

1 Old Grand Dad 114

Old Grand Dad 114

★ 9.8114pf$35 ($24 pd)

Delicious with a capital D. So sweet, you feel a little spice so you know you are drinking bourbon but not too much

2 Maker's Mark Cellar Aged Limited Edition 2024 Release

Maker's Mark Cellar Aged Limited Edition 2024 Release

★ 9.5

Strong deep notes. Sweetness sits in the back of your tongue before finishing w slight spice.

3 Elijah Craig Small Batch

Elijah Craig Small Batch

★ 9.494pf$27 ($29 pd)

Sweet & Smooth. Not spicey

4 Nine Banded Straight

Nine Banded Straight

★ 9.480pf$24.99 ($28 pd)

Smooth and light

5 Old Grand-Dad Bonded

Old Grand-Dad Bonded

★ 9.3100pf$35.99 ($25 pd)

Delicious. Complex, light sweet notes with low spicy finish

6 Sazerac Rye

Sazerac Rye

★ 9.390pf$28

Light sweetness. Threatens to get spicy but doesn't. Light leathery taste (in a good way). Bought 2nd bottle (1/28/2026) and still love it

7 Buffalo Trace

Buffalo Trace

★ 9.290pf$25

Buffalo Trace offers a balanced profile with notes of vanilla, toffee, and a hint of oak, leading to a smooth and slightly spicy finish. It's a reliable and approachable bourbon for many occasions.

8 Bulleitâ„¢ Bourbon

Bulleitâ„¢ Bourbon

★ 9.290pf$30

Mildly sweet, not spicey

9 Wathen's Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Wathen's Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

★ 9.294pf$25

A little peaty but smooth finish, mildly sweet

10 Evan Williams BIB

Evan Williams BIB

★ 9100pf$25.99 ($13 pd)

Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond is a robust and flavorful Kentucky straight bourbon with a slightly higher proof. Expect notes of caramel, oak, and a touch of spice.

11 Bushmills Irish Whiskey

Bushmills Irish Whiskey

★ 8.880pf$32.5 ($22 pd)

Bushmills Irish Whiskey is a classic example of Irish blended whiskey, offering a smooth and approachable profile with fruity and honeyed notes. It's known for its triple distillation, contributing to its lighter and cleaner character.

12 Nine Banded Cask Strength

Nine Banded Cask Strength

★ 8.6119pf$75 ($32 pd)

Interesting sweet notes. Doesn't end with spice but not a hard sweet flavor. Taste brown sugar.

13 Crown Royal

Crown Royal

★ 8.480pf$30.99

Crown Royal is a blended Canadian whisky known for its smooth, approachable profile with notes of vanilla, caramel, and light fruit. It's a versatile whisky, enjoyable neat, on the rocks, or in cocktails.

14 Russell's Reserve 10yr

Russell's Reserve 10yr

★ 8.490pf$34
15 1876 (Dripping Springs Distillery)

1876 (Dripping Springs Distillery)

★ 8.284pf$33

Nutty barn flavor. Cobbler, pecan. Not spicy. Very different profile

16 Evan Williams Black

Evan Williams Black

★ 886pf$20 ($13 pd)

Sweet without a big burn

17 Knob Creek Rye

Knob Creek Rye

★ 8100pf$29 ($33 pd)

Not too sweet. A little spicy

18 Old Forester 100

Old Forester 100

★ 8100pf$28 ($25 pd)

Old Forester 100 is a robust and flavorful bourbon with a rich caramel sweetness balanced by spicy oak and a hint of leather. It offers a long, warming finish with notes of toffee and dried fruit.

19 Traveler's

Traveler's

★ 7.9$20 ($34 pd)

Smooth & Sweet. Not very complex

20 Tincup

Tincup

★ 7.780pf$26

Lighter than others in this category. Smoother however with little to no spice.

21 Jim Beam Black

Jim Beam Black

★ 7.690pf$30.99

A bit spicy but has some nice sweet notes

22 Maker's Mark Straight

Maker's Mark Straight

★ 7.5$24
23 Redemption

Redemption

★ 7.488pf$25

Not bad for the price